Goodman: Did Alabama make a mistake by naming Ty Simpson the starter?

The Alabama Crimson Tide’s 2024 season hinges on the arm of Ty Simpson, a highly-regarded five-star recruit who has patiently waited his turn. After years of development, the spotlight now falls on Simpson, whose limited appearances have offered tantalizing glimpses of his potential. While his stat line—14 completions for 167 yards and a rushing touchdown—doesn’t tell the full story, it hints at the raw talent that convinced the coaching staff to entrust him with the starting quarterback role.

Simpson’s journey to the starting position was not without its challenges. He faced a spirited competition during spring practices from fellow quarterbacks Keelon Russell and Austin Mack, both vying for the coveted spot. Ultimately, offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb’s assessment of Simpson’s accuracy, mastery of the playbook, and advanced ability to decipher defensive schemes tipped the scales in his favor. Grubb saw in Simpson a quarterback capable of executing the complex offensive strategies that the team plans to implement.

Head Coach Kalen DeBoer’s endorsement of Simpson has been equally emphatic. DeBoer has publicly lauded Simpson’s arm strength, football intelligence, and on-field leadership, suggesting that the young quarterback possesses the qualities necessary to guide the Crimson Tide to victory. Moreover, Simpson’s playing style, characterized by his composure in the pocket, pinpoint accuracy, and thoughtful decision-making, appears to align seamlessly with DeBoer’s offensive philosophy. This synergy between player and system has fueled optimism among fans and analysts alike.

However, the upcoming season will be a crucible for Simpson. Alabama’s schedule is a gauntlet, featuring clashes against formidable opponents like Georgia, LSU, and Texas. These high-stakes matchups will test Simpson’s mettle, demanding consistent excellence under intense pressure. The ability to perform in these high-profile games will be the true measure of his readiness to lead the team. The coaching staff’s confidence in Simpson is clear, but the ultimate verdict will be rendered on the field, where his performance will determine if Alabama’s gamble pays off.