Breaking News: Dolphins Free Agents 2025 – Walk, Tag, Re-sign: Tyler Huntleys Future
As the 2025 NFL season approaches, the Miami Dolphins are faced with crucial decisions regarding their roster, including which of their free agents they should retain or let go. Among the players whose futures are in question is quarterback Tyler Huntley, whose performance as a backup has drawn significant attention and speculation. The Dolphins have several key players to decide on, but none are as intriguing as the 2025 free agency status of Huntley, especially with the question of whether Miami should opt to walk away, place a franchise tag on him, or re-sign him for the future.
The Context: Tyler Huntley’s Rise
Tyler Huntley, who first gained recognition for his role as the backup quarterback for the Baltimore Ravens, was acquired by the Miami Dolphins to provide depth behind the starting quarterback. Huntley’s reputation as a reliable signal-caller with the ability to step up in critical moments has made him an asset to the Dolphins’ locker room. While he may not be a starting quarterback in the traditional sense, his versatility and leadership in relief situations have made him a valuable piece in Miami’s offensive lineup.
Before discussing the decision to walk, tag, or re-sign Huntley, it’s essential to understand the dynamics of his performance in recent years, both with Baltimore and Miami. Huntley entered the 2025 free agency period as a key consideration for the Dolphins.
The Quarterback Landscape in 2025
As the NFL continues to evolve, quarterback play remains the most essential aspect of any team’s success. The 2025 season will be pivotal for the Dolphins, who are looking to solidify their position in the AFC East and compete for a deep playoff run. The team currently has Tua Tagovailoa as their starter, and he is entering his prime, but backup quarterbacks have never been more important than in today’s league. With a shift in the way teams approach depth at quarterback, backup signal-callers who can step in and perform at a high level are increasingly seen as invaluable.
For Miami, Tyler Huntley represents a unique challenge. While he is not expected to start over Tua, Huntley’s skill set as a reliable backup who can execute in a variety of offensive systems gives the Dolphins the flexibility to navigate injuries, providing a safety net if Tua’s health is ever in question.
Option 1: Walk – Letting Huntley Go
The first option the Dolphins face is simply to let Huntley walk in free agency. From a financial standpoint, this might seem like the easiest path, especially if the team is confident in their depth at the quarterback position. The Dolphins could choose to draft a quarterback or sign a cheaper, less experienced option who would be more of a developmental project rather than an experienced backup. This option would leave Miami with extra cap space to address other pressing roster needs, including bolstering their offensive line, adding defensive playmakers, or improving the depth in other positions.
However, choosing to let Huntley go would carry risks. With Tagovailoa’s injury history and the unpredictability of the NFL season, teams have seen just how quickly a backup quarterback can be thrust into the starting role. Having a veteran like Huntley provides stability and familiarity with the team’s system. Letting him walk could leave Miami vulnerable should the worst happen to Tua, forcing the team to scramble for a capable backup at a higher price point or with less experience.
Option 2: Tag – Franchise Tagging Huntley
The second option available is for the Dolphins to use the franchise tag on Tyler Huntley. While the franchise tag is typically used to retain star players, the Dolphins could opt for this route if they believe Huntley’s backup quarterback role is indispensable and worth the investment. Using the franchise tag on Huntley would guarantee him a high salary for the upcoming season but would provide Miami with another year of control over his services.
However, the franchise tag for a quarterback can be a significant financial commitment, especially considering that Huntley, while valuable, is not viewed as an elite starter in the league. The franchise tag for quarterbacks is typically among the highest in the NFL, which could make this decision financially imprudent unless the Dolphins believe Huntley’s value justifies the investment.
This option would likely depend on the Dolphins’ assessment of their roster and their long-term vision for the quarterback position. If the team feels that Huntley’s leadership and ability to step in at a moment’s notice are worth the significant cap hit, they could opt to tag him. However, this scenario would require careful consideration of how it would impact the team’s financial flexibility and their ability to address other key positions.
Option 3: Re-sign – Keeping Huntley for the Long Term
The third and perhaps most likely option is for the Dolphins to re-sign Tyler Huntley to a longer-term deal that is more financially sustainable. This option would allow the team to keep Huntley on the roster without the massive cap hit that would come with a franchise tag, while also locking him down as a dependable backup quarterback for the foreseeable future.
Re-signing Huntley could be an attractive option for both sides. For Huntley, the Dolphins’ system has provided him with valuable experience and exposure, making it a potential landing spot for him to continue his career as a key backup quarterback in the NFL. For Miami, Huntley provides a reliable backup who is familiar with the team’s offensive philosophy and can step in seamlessly if needed. Furthermore, re-signing Huntley to a more affordable contract would allow the Dolphins to allocate more resources to other areas of need.
The downside to re-signing Huntley, however, is that he may seek a more significant role elsewhere. While he has been a reliable backup, Huntley might want a chance to compete for a starting position or could command more money on the open market. Miami would need to weigh the potential cost of re-signing him against the need for roster flexibility in other positions.
The Decision Making Process: What Should Miami Do?
So, what’s the best course of action for the Dolphins when it comes to Tyler Huntley? Several factors need to be considered before making a decision. These factors include:
1. Tua Tagovailoa’s Health
The primary concern when evaluating Huntley’s future in Miami is Tua Tagovailoa’s health. Tua has dealt with several concussions in his career, which has raised questions about his long-term availability. While the Dolphins are hopeful that Tua will remain healthy, they must prepare for the possibility that he could miss time during the 2025 season. Huntley’s value as a reliable backup quarterback becomes even more apparent if the Dolphins are forced to rely on him for extended periods of time.
If the team believes that Tua’s health could continue to be a concern, they may choose to re-sign Huntley or use the franchise tag to ensure that they have a reliable option ready to step in if necessary.
2. Financial Flexibility
Another critical factor is the Dolphins’ overall financial situation. Miami will likely have a significant salary cap situation to navigate, with key decisions to make regarding extensions for other players, such as wide receiver Tyreek Hill and defensive stalwart Javon Holland. If the Dolphins have the financial flexibility to retain Huntley without compromising other areas of the roster, then re-signing him could make sense.
On the other hand, if Miami’s cap space is tight, they may opt to let Huntley walk or use the tag as a temporary solution while they explore other options.
3. The Market for Backup Quarterbacks
Finally, Miami will need to consider the market for backup quarterbacks. While Huntley has proven his worth as a reliable backup in the NFL, there is always the possibility that other teams could offer him a more lucrative contract or a more significant role. If Huntley is in high demand, Miami may find themselves bidding against other teams, which could complicate the decision-making process.
If the Dolphins feel confident that they can replace Huntley with a cheaper or equally capable backup, they may choose to let him walk. However, if Huntley is the best option available, Miami may prioritize retaining him.
Conclusion: The Path Ahead
Tyler Huntley’s future with the Miami Dolphins will ultimately come down to several key factors, including Tua Tagovailoa’s health, the team’s financial situation, and the market for backup quarterbacks. While the franchise tag may seem like a drastic move for a player of Huntley’s caliber, it could be a prudent decision if the Dolphins view him as a key insurance policy. Alternatively, re-signing him to a long-term deal could provide stability at the backup quarterback position, allowing the team to focus its financial resources on other areas of the roster.
As the 2025 NFL free agency period approaches, all eyes will be on the Dolphins’ decision regarding Tyler Huntley. Will they walk away from him, tag him for another year, or re-sign him for the future? The answer could shape the trajectory of Miami’s season and beyond.
Be the first to comment